1 arrested in Richmond teen murder case, gunman still at-large

‘The wheel of justice is starting to turn’
Published: Sep. 20, 2022 at 4:50 PM EDT|Updated: Sep. 20, 2022 at 5:07 PM EDT
Email This Link
Share on Pinterest
Share on LinkedIn

RICHMOND, Va. (WWBT) - Richmond court records show 25-year-old Rarmil Coley-Pettiford is facing a pair of charges in connection with the shooting death investigation of a teenager in Gilpin Court.

While police don’t believe he killed Tynashia Humphrey that night, they say he was driving the BMW in the drive-by shooting.

“They say in the affidavit during the interview he admitted to operating the vehicle the day before. With that, they obtained a search warrant,” said Steven Benjamin, NBC12 Legal Analyst.

Coley-Pettiford is facing one count of attempted murder and one count of using a firearm in the commission of a felony.

At an address listed on the warrant on the city’s southside, his father told NBC12 off camera that his son is a good kid who had lived in Richmond all his life.

“What I see here is exactly what we would expect to see in a good investigation. Search warrants being issued, seeking forensic evidence,” said Benjamin.

The search warrant details a chaotic scene that night.

Humphrey, a 9th grader at Armstrong High School, was walking to a convenience store on Sept. 12 when she was shot and killed.

She was found unresponsive on a sidewalk.

Police say she was not the intended target but instead caught in the crossfire.

Detectives say they found multiple bullet casings from two types of guns at the scene, a nine-millimeter and a rifle.

A witness on the scene said they saw the BMW slowly approach from the intersection of Charity and 1st, with gunfire coming from the front passenger side.

The warrant also says surveillance cameras captured the murder.

A day after, police were able to track down the BMW and arrest its driver, Coley-Pettiford.

The warrant says an officer saw both ammunition found at the scene and in his vehicle.

“They are doing what they should. They are trying to determine forensically if there is a link between the cartridge casings found in the vehicle and the cartridge cases found at the crime scene,” said Benjamin.

Ricky Johnson, the cousin of Humphrey, said his heart is finally starting to heal after he received a call about the arrest last week.

“When I got the call, we were overjoyed because a lot of times families go so many months and years without knowing anything,” Johnson said.

While one arrest has been made, Johnson said his cousin’s father is still going through the pain.

“My cousin is still numb at the loss of his daughter. You don’t know the bond that a father has with their child,” Johnson said. “You know so many people say we know how you feel. We understand your pain, but at the end of the day, if you haven’t lost a child and you haven’t lost a bond with your daughter, it’s totally different.”

Johnson said he just hopes this can lead to even more arrests and the person who fired the gun.

“We want to get every single person that was involved. We want every person to be held accountable,” Johnson said. “From the person that was driving the car, the person that shot the weapon, the people that was with them, whoever had any involvement in this situation.”

Police and the commonwealth’s attorney won’t comment on the investigation. A court hearing for Coley-Pettiford is set for Oct. 11. A call to his attorney has also not been returned.

Richmond police still want tips from the community to find the rest of the people involved in this crime. You can call crime stoppers anonymously at 804-780-1000.